Ale dla reszty umieszczam opracowanie dlaczego Ariel jest bezkonkurencyjnym proszkiem do prania
Experiment date: 11th September 2003
Aim: The Aim of the experiment is to check witch detergent that was to us provided has the most cleaning power and the best price.
Hypothesis: My hypothesis is that all of the detergents will have a similar cleaning power, because their prices are similar.
- Tide Lemon 18.50 EEK
- Omo Color 22.00 EEK
- Ariel 17.00 EEK
- Bold 2 in 1 19.00 EEK
This means for me that the productions costs of each where close to each other.
Apparatus: The materials that where used to do the experiment are:
- 4 pieces of fibber (white color)
- 2L container to measure the water amount.
- Sink
- 30ml container to measure the detergent amount.
Materials used to damage and to make the fiber dirty:
- Chocolate
- Baby Food (liver with carrot flavor)
- Tomato paste
- Peanut butter
- Oil
- Marker pen
- Dessert syrup
- Jam
- Coffee
- Blue Dye
The detergents:
- Tide Lemon
- Omo color
- Ariel
- Bold 2 in 1
Method: For all the detergents I used the same method.
- Chocolate: Rubbed into the fiber.
- Baby food: thrown and smashed into the fiber.
- Tomato paste: rubbed into the fiber.
- Peanut butter: rubbed into the fiber.
- Oil: putted on the fiber.
- Marker pen: drawn on the fiber.
- Desert syrup: put it on the fiber.
- Jam: putted on the fiber.
- Coffee: putt it over the fibber and smash it in with a spoon.
- Blue dye: pure it over and make it dry.
The cleaning was done in 2L of warm water and by using 15g of each detergent. The fiber was in first watered and afterwards cleaned by rubbing it in all the ways. The water temperature was light war and every fiber was washed in the detergent 3minutes.
Result: The fibers where cleaned and dried the results for each one are:
1. Omo color:
- Cleaning result was average
- Smell pretty bad
2. Bold 2 in 1
- Cleaning result is good
- Smells average
3. Tide Lemon
- Cleaning result is good
- Smell good
4. Ariel
- Cleaning result is very good
- Smell is average
Discussion: All the detergents show a very similar effect for cleaning; there are no big differences in the quality of cleaning. Most of the dirt came off.
1. The process used in cleaning all the pieces of fiber was the same for each detergent. First I put into the 2L container warm water to put it afterwards into the sink. Then I add into the water 15g of the detergent. The piece of fiber was inside squirreled and rubbed to itself in a approximately time of 3 minutes.
2. When the process of cleaning was accomplished the water from the sink was removed and the fiber was put under warm running water to get the detergent out from the fiber.
3. To dry the fibers they where put on the radiator in Mr. Brookes room. Where it was drying 2 weeks long.
I. Chocolate:
- Omo color removed the whole chocolate dirt.
- Bold 2 in 1 removed the chocolate completely.
- Tide Lemon removed the chocolate completely.
- Ariel cleaned the chocolate completely.
II. Baby food:
- Omo color left a light brown mark on the fiber.
- Bold 2 in 1 left a very light brown mark that is visible only when we stare closely on the fiber.
- Tide Lemon left a visible brown mark on the fiber that to compare to the rest of the detergents is the strongest.
- Ariel removed the baby food so that there are no visible marks on the fiber.
III. Tomato paste:
- Omo color cleaned the whole fiber.
- Bold 2 in 1 cleaned the whole fiber.
- Tide Lemon cleaned the whole fiber.
- Ariel cleaned the whole fiber.
IV. Peanut Butter:
- Omo color left a visible brown green mark on the fiber.
- Bold 2 in 1 left a visible brown mark on the fiber
- Tide Lemon left a light visible mark on the fiber.
- Ariel left an almost non- visible mark on the fiber.
V. Oil
- Omo color left a visible mark on the fiber.
- Bold 2 in 1 left no visible mark on the fiber even when I put a heavy light on the fiber no mark from oil was visible.
- Tide Lemon left a light visible mark on the fiber.
- Ariel left a very heavily visible mark on the fiber, almost cleaning it.
VI. Marker pens
- For all the detergents the result stays the same the ink from the marker pen did not came off. Most probably the reason for this is that marker pens contain alcohol and burn the fiber what helps the ink to stay in the fiber for a long time. I believe that bleaching the fiber would help, however no bleach was provided.
VII. Dessert Syrup:
- Omo color left a orange mark on the fiber.
- Bold 2 in 1 left a light orange mark on the fiber.
- Tide lemon left a medium orange mark on the fiber.
- Ariel was the only detergent that completely removed the syrup from the fiber.
VIII. Jam:
- Omo color left a high visible brown mark on the fiber.
- Bold 2 in 1 left a good visible mark on the fiber.
- Tide Lemon left a good visible mark on the fiber.
- Ariel left a light mark on the fiber.
IX. Coffee:
- Omo color left a light mark on the fiber.
- Bold 2 in 1 left a light visible mark on the fiber
- Tide Lemon cleaned completely the fiber.
- Ariel cleaned completely the fiber.
X. Blue Dye:
- The result for all the detergents is the same the fiber is clean and there is no visible mark that could say that there is some of the Blue Dye left.
1. Evaluation of the whole process:
The method that was used helped me to control all the variables very closely. Because there was the same amount of detergent used in all the single cleanings the results where similar to each other. Therefore the method used in my testing is reliable.
2. Ideas for Improvements:
To improve the method I would create a better environment to test all the detergent:
- Instead of using a sink using a bigger container.
- Make an accurate temperature measurement.
- Use rubber glows to avoid touching the fiber during washing and involving all the soils and fat that is present in our skin. This would help us also to keep our hands in a good condition.
3. Areas that let me down:
Maybe the process of observation all the fiber after the cleaning was a bit of difficult because of my limitations in looking for details.
4. Variables:
- Temperature
- Amount of the detergent
- Amount of water
- Method of rubbing the fiber
Conclusion: The aim of this experiment was the best combination of price and cleaning power. There where many kinds of materials used that are present in our every day life and that can make our cloth dirty. To proceed we put the material on the 4 pieces of fiber to make them dirty. By the process of cleaning and controlling variables I made my statement that all the detergents show no big difference in cleaning maybe except Ariel that got the best mark in the whole experiment. Otherwise all the detergents are same as good and the prices are also similar. Nevertheless at home I would use Ariel.
Zakochany w usmiechu Smoczka
------------------------------
<:Kawosz:> <:niepoprawny filozof:> <:amator fitnessu:>
Shelly
Sliwulla
Grasik
