michał

Michał,dzięki za przetłumaczenie mojego postu. Dodam tylko jedno - nie róbcie z Bruce Lee człowieka, który nie umiał się wypowiadać lub mówił szyfrem, a klucz deszyfrujący przekazał jedynie Tedowi WongowiPrzesłanie Bruce'a dotyczące Jeet Kune Do jest dla mnie jasne jak słońce . Zmieniony przez - buczah w dniu 2008-11-04 18:03:23

I quess that I know well, what in Poland it is all about My opinnion of what you are doing was based on demos of yours school which was posted on R.Karpinski website. After my comment on it you have deleted the video.... Anyway the problem does not lies in my certainity that as you claim I don't know what in Poland it is all about. From the very [...]

Stefan, Im curious to see the clip you described earlier. It is really hard to compare anything you do not see with what you were learned. Concerning the on-guard stance, I personally think that due to difference in people, every one person has its own. At least I forego many tests every time a new technique is shown to me, be it stance or a [...]

I won't give up I never will. I will not back down. I am very greatetful and thankful for the fact that I was able to meet you Stefan. The one with whom not only can I share my opinion on JKD but also about life. I am honoured to be your JKD brother. I will be doing my best and I am thankful so much that you are supporting me. I know that this [...]

As I told before (it might have been in Polish, so I'm not accusing you of not reading ) I train under instructor Robert Karpinski. Unfortunately, I personally haven't been able to meet the gurus as yet, but Robert attended trainings under Dan Inosanto for 2 months during his trip (please visit the blog from this journey - [...]

Merkavorth, from your replies I conclude that you aren't reading whole of my posts and posts which Stefan wrote either, or you don't understand them as they should be understood. First of all in the old post I wrote about scientific structure of JKD on guard stance, then I gave the examples connected with literature I mean take any poem of a [...]

Um, hello? I just answered the 3 questions pointed out by Stefan?.. The reason people leave the discussion is they get tired with one-way tirade cut-ins. You Michal do not seek peace, therefore I end my part in the dialogue. I too would rather simply show you what "my incoherent approach" is capable of. And I would. Time is precious, [...]

The problem is, they won't say to you "We're not giving away facts" They simply will remain silent, so you won't ever be 100% sure. And I wasn't speaking about attending 10 hour seminars in case of coach Robert, I was speaking about regular meetings with Matt Teasdale from Ron Balicki's english Phoenix Academy. As well as 2 month long [...]

I didn't say JKD is better than JKD concepts becouse Bruce made this. What I said was that JKD concepts isn't Bruce Lee's art anymore and even that it is even closer to Russian Martial arst than to Bruce Lee's art. After that I said that Ted Wong is said to be the purest strain of JKD- the closest to Bruce Lee, that this is authentic Bruce Lee's [...]

So you think that JKD concepts is better becouse and fit to our modern times just becouse it has grappling? I mean does anyone in the street when you fight on hard surface is using grappling? In tournaments yes, In street I doubt it. My question is why JKD concepts people say that JKD is whatever you want and is a mixture of 27 MA which I have [...]

Merkavorth Your explanation "I have never met anyone who has"- is very childish don't you think so ? Why don't you take up the discussion, Why is it such a problem for you? Kenjiro, You said- " I know Who You are etc." Man you don't even know me. If we are looking back then, you were proclaiming some time ago that you are [...]

I am so in!!!!! One more thing, Kenjiro I read article about evolution of JKD on your website. And you signed under it so I quess you know and you are confident enough to stand for what you have written there. You wrote that Bruce Lee and Dan Inosanto looked through over 200 different martial arts and saw that all of them have got some techniques [...]

yyy Michal think twice I wrote many times what I wanted to konw "why JKD fighters don't start in turnaments like MMA or if they started why they wouldn't won anything" In my opinion JKD concepcs is better than JKD (everything must evolve) you wrote that JKD is evective we can only check this by turnaments I have never written what is [...]

Stefan great story about bulls and cows :D- Understood. Yes Stefx you didn't wrote directly that Ted Wong Stefan or me are wrong but between the lines- that's what I concluded. But I didn't say that you did. I have asked you why don't all of the people who were so strongly attacking me that I am stuck at one point, that Bruce Lee was wrong becouse [...]

Stefan you made me laugh :D Of course about my mam and dad you WON :) but in my opinion it is dangerous to attack "vital points" for us defenders (in Polish law) if you hurt to much "your" attacker or you kill him you can have big problems sa I prefer "normal" defend :P unfourtunately we can only check [...]

I got an idea of putting those clips druing the time when I was at my work But as everyone can witness Stefan is faster And did it before my action. I also realized that he does the same thing very often when he is wearing gloves and headgear. I was able to feel that on my "head-gear";)- "OUCH" . I wanted to do that to [...]

If we base on clip which Michal presented, JKD was the art of kicking something between yoko and mawashi with a front leg. And even If, for someone so agile and quick like bruce, it was enough, for typical fighter like me and you it's not sufficent to face opponent from other contact martial arts. And that's why concepts are closer to every of us, [...]

I must say that from my own experience I know that when sparring with Stefan every move becomes very risky manouver and I am not talking only about attacking I am atalking about moving also and even breathing. I said I know that, but I also felt that. The matter of the front hand position had been discussed over once in this debate. The reason for [...]

Buczah wrote: Hold on a sec, video clip with Dan Inosanto is an instructional video about Jun Fan Gung Fu not JKD". Now you are jumping into your own misconclusions. Why? You must have forgotten that Dan Inosanto said that Jun Fan Gung Fu is the base system for the JKD right, and that JKD is just an idea where you take techniques from other [...]

Here is the rest part of the text which Buczah wrote after editing his text beside that in the clip Inosanto is presenting JF Gung Fu and not JKD. He said that he "...partic****ted in Ron Balcicki seminar. And that for long time he didn't see such perfectionism in techniques and power in movements and such versatility about which Ted Wong [...]